Phil Rosenthal Had To Fight CBS Over Potentially Firing One Of The Main Cast Members On Everybody Loves Raymond


  • Phil Rosenthal almost quit Everybody Loves Raymond due to a disagreement with CBS over casting choices for the role of Debra.
  • Despite CBS’s preference, Rosenthal convinced them to hire Patricia Heaton for the role after a disastrous audition with their top choice.
  • Patricia Heaton went on to have a successful career after Everybody Loves Raymond, including roles in TV shows, films, and even her own cooking show.

Phil Rosenthal went to war with CBS over potentially firing one of the main cast members on Everybody Loves Raymond. Rosenthal, the mastermind behind the much beloved sitcom, helmed a show that not only became a staple of American television from September 13, 1996, to May 16, 2005, but also a symbol of sitcom success during its time on air. Over nine seasons and a total of 210 episodes, Everybody Loves Raymond garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated fanbase, evidenced by its 69 Primetime Emmy Award nominations and 15 wins, which included ten for acting.


Ray Romano’s Life Changed Forever When Everybody Loves Raymond Season 1 Was Greenlit

Thanks to Everybody Loves Raymond, Ray Romano has become one of the richest sitcom stars.

This widespread recognition was matched by commercial success, with lead star Ray Romano earning between $1.7 million and $1.8 million per episode at the height of the show’s popularity. Reports from CheatSheet have indicated that Romano continues to make around $18 million a year from syndications of the show. The crux of the conflict between Rosenthal and CBS centered around Patricia Heaton, who played Debra Barone on Everybody Loves Raymond.

Phil Rosenthal Almost Quit Everybody Loves Raymond After Patricia Heaton’s Casting Was Put Into Question

Phil Rosenthal smiling and standing on the red carpet
via Instar

Phil Rosenthal nearly walked away from Everybody Loves Raymond even before its premiere. This pivotal moment came as CBS decided to take a more hands-on approach in selecting the actress for a key role. They were searching for someone to play the wife of Ray Romano’s character, which ultimately became one of Patricia Heaton’s defining roles. However, Heaton was not initially on the CBS’ radar for the part, as the network had a specific vision that did not align with Rosenthal’s.

In a revealing interview with Yahoo! Entertainment in September 2021, Rosenthal shared, “CBS wanted someone hotter to play Debra,” highlighting the network’s desire for a casting choice that fit the common ’90s sitcom trope. This trope often saw less conventionally attractive male leads paired with women who looked as though they could be models. Rosenthal’s disagreement with CBS’ direction was so strong that he considered leaving his own show. “I almost quit the show over it,” he admitted.


The Future Of Everybody Loves Raymond Was In Doubt After Patricia Heaton Purposely Called In “Sick” Due To Behind The Scenes Issues

With season 8 of Everybody Loves Raymond shooting, Patricia Heaton decided to call in “sick,” while Brad Garrett didn’t show up either.

In the end, Rosenthal and Heaton won the battle against CBS, with the actress going on to feature in every one of the sitcom’s 210 episodes over a nine-year run. Her portrayal of Debra Barone earned her critical acclaim, underscored by her seven nominations for the Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series, with wins in 2000 and 2001.

How Did Phil Rosenthal Finally Convince CBS To Hire Patricia Heaton?

In his pursuit to find the perfect Debra Barone, Phil Rosenthal faced pushback from CBS over their preferred actress for the role. Despite the network’s insistence, Rosenthal’s intuition told him this choice was not right.

He shared, “I thought she was wrong, but I met with her and she was a very pleasant, very nice person. She wasn’t going to read for the role but during the meeting, I convinced her to read a little bit with me.” The reading confirmed Rosenthal’s doubts: “She was ten times worse for the part than I thought she would be!”

Armed with this conviction, Rosenthal entered discussions with CBS executives, ready to defend his vision for the character. Among his arsenal was a list of three actresses, subtly acknowledging the network’s pick while preparing to advocate for his preference.


Everybody Loves Raymond Star Doris Roberts Struggled With Terrible Health Issues Before Her Death In 2016

Doris Roberts, AKA Marie Barone on Everybody Loves Raymond, sadly suffered from a health condition before her 2016 passing.

When the then-CEO Les Moonves inquired about the network’s favorite, Rosenthal was candid. “I said, ‘I love her and I’ve loved everything she’s been in. I think she’s terrific and beautiful, but then she read for me and I have to tell you it’s just not what I wrote. I just don’t see them as a couple. I think she could do it, but I also think that maybe we could do better,'” he recounted.

The resolution came swiftly and decisively two weeks later when Heaton finally auditioned. “Two weeks later, Patty walked in and within five minutes she had the part. When it’s right, it’s right, and you know it immediately,” Rosenthal said.

What Has Patricia Heaton Been Up To Since Everybody Loves Raymond?

The season finale of Everybody Loves Raymond aired on May 16, 2005. Since then, Patricia Heaton has been actively expanding her career beyond her iconic role as Debra Barone. In 2005, she took the lead role and also stepped behind the camera to produce The Engagement Ring, a romantic comedy-drama film that earned a 62% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. The following year, she portrayed United States Ambassador Barbara Bodine in the miniseries The Path to 9/11.

Patricia Heaton’s Biggest Roles Since Everybody Loves Raymond

Movie/TV Show:


Patricia Heaton’s Role:

The Path to 9/11 (ABC)

September 2006

Barbara Bodine

Back to You (Fox)

2007 – 2008

Kelly Marsha Carr

The Middle (ABC)

2009 – 2018

Frances Patricia “Frankie” Heck

Moms’ Night Out

May 9, 2014


Patricia Heaton Parties

2015 – 2016


Heaton’s career continued to flourish with a variety of roles. From 2007 to 2008, she co-starred with Kelsey Grammer in Back to You, a Fox comedy series about news anchors, which, despite its cancellation in May 2008, earned her a Satellite Award nomination for Best Actress. In 2009, she began a successful nine-season run as Frankie Heck in the ABC comedy series The Middle.

In 2015, Heaton ventured into new territory with Patricia Heaton Parties, a cooking show on the Food Network that won a Daytime Emmy Award for Outstanding Culinary Program in 2016. Her film work also expanded, with roles in Mending the Line alongside Brian Cox in 2023, and a leading role in the psychological horror-thriller The Beldham the same year. Heaton’s achievements were recognized with a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame on May 22, 2012.

Source link